Category Archives: Brexit & The Future of Ireland Report

The New York Times – “U.K. Sets Out Goals for an Open Irish Border. Trade Is More Complex.”

LONDON — The militarized checkpoints that once stood along the border between Ireland and Northern Ireland became flash points for sectarian violence during the Troubles, and no one wants to see their return after Britain quits the European Union in 2019.

But a document released by the British government on Wednesday on how to preserve the open border there has underscored the sprawling complexity of Britain’s planned departure from the bloc, known as Brexit.

Northern Ireland is a part of the United Kingdom, while Ireland has been an independent nation since 1921. Both are members of the European Union — a shared status that has helped London and Dublin put aside historical differences and develop such a close relationship that border controls have disappeared. Travelers generally do not even know when they have passed from one country to the other.

After Brexit, however, the roughly 300-mile frontier with Ireland will be the United Kingdom’s only land border with a bloc whose economic arrangements, including its customs union and single market, it plans to leave. That creates a host of problems.

The customs union allows members to trade freely among themselves while charging a single tariff on some goods from nonmembers. When Britain leaves the bloc, goods crossing the border from Britain into Ireland could be subject to varying tariffs, unless the British adopt the same tariffs as the European Union or strike a special deal with it. Policing those varying tariffs could be burdensome.

The same principle holds for the single market. It is maintained through a complex and detailed set of standards that Britain would either have to abide by or face the logistical nightmare of checking goods entering the European Union from its territory.

Adopting the same tariffs and standards as the European Union would clear up a lot of problems, but would undermine the supposed purpose of Brexit in the first place, which is to re-establish control over immigration and national sovereignty. It would also complicate, or perhaps even preclude, forging trade deals with countries like the United States, another major goal of Brexit.

The document published on Wednesday represents the first, if somewhat vague, attempt to deal with these problems as they affect the Irish frontier. It rules out the reintroduction of physical infrastructure such as customs posts, and there appear to be no plans to use security cameras or license plate recognition technology at or around the border.

Immigration would not be policed at the Irish frontier, nor would there be passport checks on people entering mainland Britain from Northern Ireland.

That would seem to raise the possibility that European Union citizens could enter Britain indirectly through Ireland, perhaps undermining control over immigration. But the document hints that European citizens would probably be allowed to enter Britain freely and directly from Europe even after Brexit, though they might face some restrictions on their right to work or to claim welfare payments as people from outside the European Union do today.

The bigger problem is trade. The European Union’s chief Brexit negotiator, Michel Barnier, warned last month that “frictionless trade” would not be possible if the United Kingdom left the bloc’s economic arrangements.

Wednesday’s document calls on the European Union to agree to a series of waivers for small businesses and farmers, to avoid the need for them to complete customs formalities.

But that is only part of the problem. Even if that were agreed, larger companies would surely face higher costs. The British government is hazy on this point, talking about setting up simplified customs procedures and applying technologies — so far unspecified — to track goods, reduce bureaucracy and prevent costly delays.

British officials say there is so far no estimate of the increased cost that some businesses would face. Stephen Martin, the director general of the Institute of Directors, a business lobby group, described the document as a “significant step forward,” while adding that it “throws up even more questions about how much flexibility and imagination will be needed to overcome some very fundamental challenges.”

John Bruton, a former Irish prime minister, said the document failed to address the need for tariffs to be collected by Ireland on some goods imported into the European Union. “Brexit is going to increase the cost of doing business,” he told the BBC.

Farmers may have to adapt, too. More than 10,000 pigs are exported from Ireland to Northern Ireland every week, while a quarter of all milk produced by dairies in Northern Ireland is exported to Ireland for processing.

To minimize disruptions to trade, the document suggests setting common regulatory standards on agricultural products traded between the United Kingdom and the European Union. Yet that could complicate London’s efforts to strike global trade deals with countries such as the United States, if they involve importing agricultural goods.

Ireland’s government gave the document a polite but cautious reception, with its foreign minister, Simon Coveney, welcoming the principles behind its approach. Yet he added, according to the Irish broadcaster RTE, “What we don’t have, though, is the detail as to how it’s going to work.”

Mark Daly, a senior member of Ireland’s opposition Fianna Fail party, was less diplomatic, describing the plan as “pie in the sky” and warning that the proposals amounted to a “smugglers’ charter.”


Comments Off on The New York Times – “U.K. Sets Out Goals for an Open Irish Border. Trade Is More Complex.”

Filed under A United Ireland in Peace and Prosperity, Brexit & The Future of Ireland Report

Derry Journal – “‘We are not leaving our own nation state’”

DUP MP Gregory Campbell has said that there is not going to be any united Ireland in a response to a new report stating that groundwork should begin for a future referendum.

Mr Campbell made his views known following the publication of an official report on the Republic of Ireland entitled ‘Brexit and the Future of Ireland, Uniting Ireland & Its People in Peace and Prosperity’.

The report called for preparations to begin for a “pathway to achieve the peaceful reunification of Ireland.”

It also called for unionist fears to be addressed in preparation for a future referendum on Irish reunification.

Responding via his Facebook profile, Mr Campbell said: “The Republic has now set out its stall. I presume they would like responses.

“My response: We are British, we are not leaving our own Nation State precisely BECAUSE we are British.

“We would like good relations with your Country after we gain freedom from the bureaucratic EU which has cost our Nation hundreds of billions, but there is not going to be a United Ireland, either peacefully or any other way.

“Those good relations will operate much better if we all understand exactly where each other stands,” he added.

The Joint Committee on the Implementation of the Good Friday Agreement published the report, which was compiled by Senator Mark Daly, last week.

Its findings, based on detailed research and examinations of key reports, included input from former Taoiseach Bertie Ahern, senior international politicians, expert European Professors and Counter Terrorism experts from the US

In light of its obligations under the Good Friday Agreement, the Irish Government has now been tasked to look at the legal and constitutional changes necessary before and after unification, and also to negotiate for the North to be designated special status EU and to have continued access to EU funds post Brexit.

The report states: “Brexit means that the best future for the citizens of Northern Ireland could well be remaining in the European Union in a reunified Ireland. This option must be explored.”

Sinn Féin MP, Elisha McCallion, has said the report launch “makes the case for the need for a Joint-Oireachtas Committee on Irish Unity much more compelling,” adding: “The establishment of such a committee would further research, develop and utilise the detail collated in this report and also help action and scrutinise government obligations on planning for unity within the context of both the Good Friday Agreement and the negative ramifications of Brexit.”

SDLP Leader Colum Eastwood MLA also welcomed the report and repeated his call for nationalism across the island to advance the process of mapping Irish unity in a way that includes and respects all traditions. He said: “The SDLP continues to believe that Irish unification is the biggest and the best idea around. This report should now prompt a national discussion on unity, our constitutional and economic future that includes and respects all traditions on the island.”

“Irish nationalism needs to get down to the kind of work undertaken by Scottish nationalists in advance of their independence referendum.”

Comments Off on Derry Journal – “‘We are not leaving our own nation state’”

Filed under Brexit & The Future of Ireland Report

BBC News: “Reality Check: Ireland’s border and Brexit”

BBC News:

The claim: There are more border crossings in Ireland than on the whole of the EU’s eastern border.

Reality Check verdict: This is true – there are 137 land border crossings to the east of the EU, compared with 275 between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland.

Senator Mark Daly, deputy leader of Fianna Fail, was on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme on Wednesday, discussing the complexities of the Irish border.

“There are over 300 miles of border between the north and south of Ireland,” he said.

“And there are more border crossings on this island than there is between the European Union and all the countries to the east of it.”

It is hard to find a precise figure for the number of land border crossings in Ireland, because there is no definitive view of how major a track or path has to be before it counts as a border crossing.

A reasonable figure, though, comes from a website called, which has an interactive map showing the location of 275 crossings.

During the Troubles, only 20 of them were open.

What makes the border particularly tricky is that some roads cross the border several times, especially around Fermanagh.

This is in stark contrast to the eastern border of the EU. On the border between Poland and Ukraine, for example, looking at a map there are only 11 crossings on a 330-mile border and most of them are on major roads.

Information about the EU’s eastern border comes from Frontex, the European border and coastguard agency.

It measures the land border as being 6,000km (3,720 miles) long, covering the borders between EU member states and Belarus, Moldova, Ukraine and Russia.

It cannot give a figure for the number of roads crossing that border, but it sent a link to a list of borders in EU states. The list was prepared as part of the establishment of the Schengen passport-check-free zone that runs along much of the eastern border of the EU (although not all – Romania, for example, is an EU member but not part of Schengen).

So the Romanian borders are based on just counting from a map.

Frontex does not consider the borders with Turkey to be part of the eastern border, although if they were counted there are two land borders with Greece and four between Bulgaria and Turkey (those also counted on a map).

So that gives a total figure of 137 land border crossings, about half as many as there are in Ireland, despite being 12 times its length.

Comments Off on BBC News: “Reality Check: Ireland’s border and Brexit”

Filed under Brexit & The Future of Ireland Report

“Donegal TDs react to the first report on the prospect of a united Ireland”

Donegal Now:

The Oireachtas has published its first report since the 1984 New Ireland Forum, on the achievement of a united Ireland.

“Brexit and the Future of Ireland: Uniting Ireland and its People in Peace and Prosperity” was published by the Oireachtas Joint Committee on the Good Friday Agreement.

According to its rapporteur, Senator Mark Daly, Fianna Fáil Seanad Spokesperson on Foreign Affairs, the report detailed post-Brexit options for the island of Ireland.

Senator Daly added: “’Brexit and the Future of Ireland: Uniting Ireland and its People in Peace and Prosperity’ looked at the impact of Brexit on Ireland and what needed to happen in order to peacefully achieve a United Ireland.

Donegal TD, Charlie McConalogue (Fianna Fáil) reiterated Senator Daly’s comments.

He said: “There is significant support in Ireland in favour of a United Ireland, with some polls showing support in excess of 80 percent.

“’Brexit and the Future of Ireland: Uniting Ireland and its People in Peace and Prosperity’ is a step forward but it is only a start.

“We all need to do more to bring about a United Ireland through active consent. That process starts now.

Peaceful unification

“Of the 17 recommendations by the committee, one of the key ones is the need to establish a New Ireland Forum II, to set a pathway to achieve the peaceful unification of Ireland.

“This forum, in addition to hearing from those in favour of unity, must include Unionist voices and perspectives,” concluded Mr McConalogue.

Commenting on ‘Brexit and the Future of Ireland’, Gaeltacht Minister Joe McHugh (Fine Gael) said Brexit could not be allowed “to scupper” Peace Process gains.

He added: “As a Donegal man who is witnessing my own county moving into a new positive space, as a direct consequence of peace, I want to protect the gains.

“A border, any border outside of the existing arrangements is too big a price to pay.

“Whatever Brexit brings, the EU has a responsibility to future-proof the peace process and must be constantly reminded of its role and reminded that every person in

“Northern Ireland has a right under the Good Friday Agreement to Irish Citizenship, and therefore, EU citizenship.

“The peace process and free movement allows thousands of cross-Border journeys for work every day between Donegal and Derry.

“For example, more than 10 per cent of staff on Derry City & Strabane District Council lives in the Republic. It is vital that this continues. You cannot put a checkpoint up stopping this.

“Any slowdown in the movement of people and goods is unacceptable to citizens on both sides of the Border.

“The cancer care centre at Altnagelvin and the cardiac unit there now treat hundreds of patients from Donegal, many from Inishowen. More lives are being saved in ways we never expected as a result of the peace process.”

Donegal Senator Pádraig Mac Lochlainn (Sinn Féin) described the Oireachtas report as “a good start”.

He said: “The current debate around Brexit demonstrates again the folly of the border and the partition of this island.

“No where has suffered more from the effects of partition than Inishowen and the North West border region.

“Two economies, two taxation systems, two health systems, two education systems, developed on a small island of 6.5 million people, back to back, over the years, does not make sense.

“It is a duplication of vital resources and fails our people and our communities, particularly along the border.”

Comments Off on “Donegal TDs react to the first report on the prospect of a united Ireland”

Filed under Brexit & The Future of Ireland Report

Evening Standard – “Northern Ireland border plan ‘will be back door for EU smugglers'”

Britain’s proposals for a customs arrangement with the EU has been labelled a “smugglers’ charter” in a damning critique by a leading Irish politician. 

Kate Proctor, Evening Standard:

The Government’s latest Brexit position paper on Northern Ireland suggests goods could travel freely between the UK and Irish Republic after Britain leaves the EU without the need for a hard border.

Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, James Brokenshire, said border checks would not be necessary if modern technology was put in place and described the plans as “imaginative”.

But Senator Mark Daly, deputy leader of the Irish opposition party Fianna Fáil, said the proposals would only exacerbate existing cross-border smuggling.

He said: “It would be a smugglers charter. Our border would be a back door into Europe so people would import goods that are cheaper under tariff arrangements with the UK then bring them into the Republic, then onto the EU.”

“The UK want to advantage economically over the EU and will do preferential trade agreements with none EU countries — that becomes a smugglers’ charter. We already have a smuggling problem while both jurisdictions are within the EU.”

He also doubted the UK’s optimism their proposals for future customs arrangements would gain traction with the EU.

Theresa May has moved to reassure nationalists living in Northern Ireland that Brexit will not see the UK turn its back on its “unique and special relationship” with Ireland.

The Prime Minister insisted rights enshrined under the Good Friday peace accord, such as the right to claim Irish citizenship, would be protected after the exit from the European Union. Her direct message to the nationalist community in the Belfast-based Irish News, said: “No one voted to end the special ties between the UK and Ireland or to undermine the unique arrangements between Ireland and Northern Ireland which have underpinned the peace process and have been in place well before our membership of the EU.”

Northern Ireland Secretary Mr Brokenshire also sought to reassure people that their customs proposals do not relate to the free movement of people between Northern Ireland and the Republic.

He said the Common Travel Agreement pre-dates EU membership and he wants to see that structure maintained.



Comments Off on Evening Standard – “Northern Ireland border plan ‘will be back door for EU smugglers'”

Filed under Brexit & The Future of Ireland Report